The main reason for the Cigar Taste Test conducted last tuesday night was to evaluate a certain cigar. The event was a success with about 14 participants attending in the Taste Test. We were given two unbanded cigars to test. The first one was a Corona and the second was a Churchill.
We had the Corona during our appetizer. Upon inspection the cigar was slightly veiny and hard. A hard pinch would crack the cigar. Cap construction was ok.
The corona started mild. Lighting was easy and burn rate was perfect and even. However that's not the case for all cigar. My mate, Roslan who was sitting on my table find it hard to draw. In terms of taste, the cigar start to give its medium bodie flavour at 50%. Slight strong/harsh taste was also detected.
Overall, i liked the cigar. It should be aged for a month or two before consuming.
However, although the cigar can be categorized as medium, the taste did not linger long enough. After the starter, we didn't notice the taste at all.
Here's my verdict on the Corona:
Appearance and Presentation: 15/20
Lighting and Burning Properties: 13/15
Construction:25/30
Taste: 32/35
Total Score: 85/100
We had the churchill right after the main course. Like the Corona, the Churchill was also hard. The cap constrction was good. Lighting up was easy, but this time all three cigars at my table had different characteristics. Mine didn't burn evenly and the ash was grey and crumbly, but the draw was excellent.
Nur find his Churchill hard to draw. The best cigar on the table was Roslan's. His cigar burned evenly and he was very happy with it. In terms of taste, the Churchill was mild-medium. We have come to terms that the cigar is a perfect companion when you have time to spare (perhaps while lounging at a pub/bar with lots of people). However it is not to be indulged-in/enjoyed alone by itself (eg. in a cigar bar).
And the Churchill:
Appearance and Presentation: 17/20
Lighting and Burning Properties: 12/15
Construction:27/30
Taste: 30/35
Total Score: 86/100
The verdict: I would say the cigars are well made despite a few inconsistencies. The construction is good and the taste is pleasant although i would say the corona is a bit strong and harsh at times. Give it a few more fine tune and it'll be perfect! Frankly speaking, it is better than a few European cigars i have tasted and even some dominican too (read: H. Uppman)! I don't mind giving it a second (or a third) try! :)
Definitely worth a try for both novice and afficionados alike.
Yeah, we're happy.
More pics at Aizuddin's!
After the test, the identity of the cigars were revealed. The cigars were actually Malaysian made under the brand De Kayang. We were fortunate to have the opportunity to talk to the gentlemen involved in the industry, and learn the process and the history of the cigar. They're one year old and going strong. Of course you cant compare them with decades old Habanos and Dominicans, but i would say it is definitely a bold start for the industry and for Malaysia. I wish them the best of luck and Malaysia Boleh!
Recent Comments